The Border Wars Between England and Scotland

400px-watharden The political struggle that has dominated much of England/Scotland’s history was often a result of the border wars. In Elizabethan times the Anglo-Scottish border counties, especially Northumberland, were the home of lawless clans who spent their lives raiding and marauding. The Border Reivers were not necessarily men of lower class. In fact, many were members of the Realm. They were excellent fighters and knew how to survive in a desolate land.

From BBC Home, we find that “Reiv” means to steal. The Reiver period is roughly categorised as 1450 – 1610. The movement came to its height in the late 1500′s and ended around 1610. The Reiver history is a mixture of fact and folklore. The English crown destroyed almost all of the documentation relating to Reiver life and so the Reiver’s story has passed down through oral history and folk traditions, rather than formal documentation. As a result, it is hard to untangle the mythological from the material when describing the Reiver movement.”

Following the Cheviot Hills, a bleak line of ridges and valleys that forms the border between England and Scotland, was the land upon which much blood was shed. Hadrian’s Wall, built by the Romans from Solway Firth to Berwick, never successfully kept either nation apart. The Chevoits sport peat bogs, broad rivers, hidden valley, salt marshes, and wooded areas. Raiding was an important way of life for those who lived on the borders. Neither treaties nor truces could prevent the continual struggle to survive in this desolate area. The purveyor of the strongest sword ruled the land.

220px-black_middens_bastle_-_geograph-org-uk_-_1224658 The Borders were not the romantic lands often portrayed in many current novels. It was a cruel, brutal land. The times were peppered with feuds between families. Clan loyalties were stronger than allegiance to either crown. Intermarriages brought about new alliances, but what really tied the area together was the geography, the belief in independence, and the society in which this people lived. English fought Scots, but they also fought Englishmen. The same held true for the Scotsmen. This created a dual nationality among men who lived along the Cheviot Hills. Not spoken of openly, it would not be unusual for the English to share “the spoils” with their Scottish brothers, or vice versa.

Autumn brought an increase in activity for the reivers. These families were often nomads, of sorts. The houses were of the type that they could be moved at a moment’s notice. We must remember that these people were violent, aggressive, and often ruthless, but they had a “sense of honor.” They consider reiving a way of life, but murder was looked down upon (even during a raid) unless there was no other option. A reiver’s object was to make a quick strike, plunder his enemy’s land, and return with his loot in tact – all this without loss of life, if possible.

400px-hermitage_castle_062 Using a series of beacons as warning signals, the retreat was the most risky part of a reiver’s foray. If he managed to avoid the local watches, the warden’s troopers, the paid militia, the broad rivers and mossy bogs, he might fall victim to the Hot Trod, the legal pursuit of the reivers, who were loaded down from their loot and by driving stolen cattle and sheep to their own keeps. During the Hot Trod, all male neighbors, between the ages of 16 and 60 of the victim, were required by law to join in the pursuit of the attackers. The posse also had the legal right to recruit others along the way. If a person refused to aid in the pursuit, he could be considered a traitor and put to death.

David Simpson of The Roots of the Region website says, ”George M Trevelyan the great British historian, (a Northumbrian) superbly summed up the nature of the Border Reivers and their ballads when he wrote;

400px-reivers_raid_on_gilnockie_tower‘They were cruel,coarse savages, slaying each other like the beasts of the forest; and yet they were also poets who could express in the grand style the inexorable fate of the individual man and woman, the infinite pity for all cruel things which they none the less inflicted upon one another. It was not one ballad- maker alone but the whole cut throat population who felt this magnanimous sorrow, and the consoling charms of the highest poetry.’ Many of the Border Ballads still survive today, due to the avid collecting of the famous Border poet, Sir Walter Scott (1771-1832), himself the descendant of a famous border clan.”

Border Clans included the Armstrongs, Bells, Cecils, Croziers, Dodds, Douglases, Elliotts, Fenwicks, Forsters, Grahams, Homes, Howards, Irvines, Johnstones, Kerrs, Maxwells, Nixons, Robsons, Scotts, Storeys, and Taits.

A superb source that summarizes and explains many of the key issues of the Border Wars is The Border Reivers.

JeffersDofGDThe remnants of the reiver huts that were used as part of the “escape routes” became part of my Austenesque novel, The Disappearance of Georgiana Darcy, which was released in March 2012. In researching these border wars for this novel, I became quite enthralled with the story lines.

ATOCcropI also used the “border wars” as part of the backdrop for the rescue of Cashémere Aldridge by the Earl of Berwick in book 3 of my highly popular Realm series, A Touch of Cashémere. Berwick’s estate was once part of Scotland, but now sits on the English side of the border.

About Regina Jeffers

Regina Jeffers is the award-winning author of Austenesque, Regency and historical romantic suspense.
This entry was posted in British history, buildings and structures, castles, Great Britain, legends and myths, political stance, real life tales, religion, royalty, Scotland and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to The Border Wars Between England and Scotland

  1. Susana Ellis says:

    Fascinating! I always learn so much from you, Regina!

Comments are closed.